I realize now that one of my biggest obstacles to overcoming bulimia is my guilt for contributing to my mom’s illness and my sister’s struggles and her ultimate suicide. Before dismissing that notion, you need to appreciate that throughout my teen years and on up until my mom died when I was 22, I was downright, persistently ugly to them both.
MOM
If you read my entry “My Crazy Family,” you know that my mom, diagnosed bi-polar, had a hell of a time dealing with even the smallest of responsibilities and challenges. I had spent a lot of time trying to be helpful and encouraging, to no avail. I had “learned” that being helpful was pretty ineffective at getting her to do the right things – like get a job, quit smoking, take care of her health, or otherwise just wake up and be present with us. It was so frustrating to me. At some point I decided, however unconsciously, to try the opposite approach - if to accomplish nothing other than to get a response out of her. Even anger, even rage, would have been welcome. I got nothing but sad silence. I don’t remember her ever yelling back. I responded with increasing rage and indignation. We had come to a tentative peace only once I had moved away to college.
LESLIE
My older sister, Leslie, was always a fish out of water. My parents had adopted her as an infant in Philadelphia and brought her home to upstate NY. Her genetics screamed big city, and yet here she was stuck in a tiny little town in the middle of nowhere. Even worse, she had 3 very typical upstate bumpkins as her family. Not only were we 3 quite at home there, we couldn’t understand for the life of us why she just couldn’t seem to fit in. Very sadly, neither could she. All she knew was that she was unhappy and very much a misfit. Not until her late 20’s was Leslie ever accepted for who she was. Labeled by teachers and her family alike as a lost, rebellious teenager, all the wonderful gifts and strengths she had been born with began to fade along with her self-esteem. Her grades fell as steadily as her weight went up. And, her quiet suffering made her the perfect target for all my rage and frustration. I was SO mean to her . . . ridiculing, blaming, screaming out her deficiencies and failures as I saw them. I made sure to remind her daily of her weight, her poor grades, her lack of boyfriends and popularity. I served as a persistent reminder to her general failure, that is, of course, until she was ready to take on that role for me. Long after I had moved away to college, her battles raged on.
I have struggled with this ugly past and my horrible guilt. I used both of them to make myself feel better – bigger, stronger, better. In so doing, I contributed to (in Leslie’s case, even planted the seeds for) their depression, self-criticism, hopelessness, and ultimate defeat. Leslie struggled so hard to find her place in the world – to fit in, feel acceptance, approval and love. At times, it appeared she had found a foothold in her struggle. 2004 had been very promising for her career and her dreams. But, I guess she was exhausted from fighting so hard and so long. At the age of 35, she gave up the fight. She took all the pills she could find or get her psychiatrist to prescribe – including Wellbutrin, Klonopin, and a couple others – and she committed suicide. She died on 1/13/04 alone in her apartment and was found 2 days later on 1/15/04. Of course, a big piece of me died that day, too.
You can see now why I struggle so much with guilt – because I’m guilty. I’m not saying I alone caused Leslie’s death or my mother’s demise. I battle too much with feelings of powerlessness to think for a moment that I had that much control over two people. I certainly, however, contributed to their depressions.
Guilt is very powerful when left to fester in one’s heart. It robs all the good, positive beliefs that are critical for living a healthy, productive, fulfilling life filled with love and friendship. I can’t enjoy my success because I feel I have won at the expense of the people closest to me. I can’t be happy or enjoy happy times when I caused so much pain and misery in people I love. I can’t love freely when I fear I will create similar anguish for those who get too close to me. I’m very good at breaking people. I am selfish, manipulative, angry, mean, ugly, hateful.
I could easily go on like this – just surviving each day without joy. Beating myself up regularly, reminding myself at times of the human destruction I have left in my wake. I’m as good at beating up myself as I am at beating up others.
The big problem? I found something I want. Something to live for. I tried to scare it away; I tried to sabotage it. It wouldn’t go. I realized, soon, that I needed it, that I wanted it more than I had wanted anything in a very long time. After awhile I understood that to truly have and keep this thing, I would have to become a much better person. There is no way I could become a better person when I spend so much of my time focusing on beating myself up over the past. I would have to forgive myself. And, I could only that if I could believe deeply in my heart that they forgive me, too. But they’re dead – how could I possibly know they forgive me?!
Yes, my mom is my mom. Certainly a mother could forgive her child for anything, right? As reasonable as this may sound, I unfortunately have a father who basically disowned me. He was disappointed in me as a person and decided his life would be happier without me in it. And, I had never even treated him badly like I had my mother. Quite a barrier to forgiveness, huh?
And, yes, I had managed in Leslie’s last few years to forge the strongest, most honest and accepting relationship I had ever experienced. I was in awe of the woman she had become. I admired, respected, needed, and loved her with all my heart. She was my best friend, confidant, and ally in the world. She was my biggest fan and I, hers. I will always be comforted that in her last visit with me – just over a month before she died- I made sure she knew of my respect and love. I remember telling her with all heart that she had become my role-model – for driving relentlessly after her dream no matter what, for her abundance of loving friends, for her amazing creativity, her bottomless giving spirit, and her complete selflessness. We both were amazed at how our roles reversed. She had become the sister with all the self-esteem and success; I was the one crippled by my bulimia. It was our most loving, laugh-filled time ever. I remember exclaiming through tears of laughter “I never realized how damn funny you are!” God, how I miss her.
So, it sounds like she had already forgiven me, huh? But, the problem is that she and I both had to forget and get over a lot of the bad stuff we experienced early on. I have no comfort that she didn’t just block it out without ever confronting the pain I had caused. She may, just to survive, have projected the blame onto my mom who was dead and gone, while I was still here. And, I do believe it was me who planted seeds of worthlessness and failure in her heart and left them for her to nurture at each hurdle or disappointment in her life. How can I possibly forgive myself for that?
Luckily for me I have a stubborn coach (NOT a therapist, mind you) whom I hired to help me through my recovery. Recently, he ignored my refusal to even address, let alone forgive, my father for being so mean-spirited and selfish at the time of Leslie’s death. And, at a moment in our work, when I was in a peak emotional state and very vulnerable, he asked if I could leave open just the tiniest bit of room in my heart in case my father at some point wanted to be back in my life. In that emotional state, it just didn’t feel right in my heart to say no. What I did say was this: “he believes it is my fault for him staying away from me. For him to even want to come back, he will have to have realized his own role and that I am not so bad that he needs to stay away. If he could come to me with that attitude, if he accepted his share of the responsibility for who I am as well as what happened to Leslie, if he could feel deeply sorry for his hurtful actions, if he could fully accept me as I am and still want me in his life unconditionally, then yes, I believe I could forgive him.”
So, wow! If I could forgive my father, then certainly my sister could forgive me! So let’s go down the list of forgiveness criteria I outlined for my dad and see if I meet them for myself:
(1) Accepts responsibility for role: yes, I completely accept responsibility for hurting Leslie as a child. We made light of it as adults, but I know I expressed to her my responsibility for probably all of our big fights. I admitted to taking out all my upset on her and I admitted that she seldom if ever attacked me except in defense. I believe she knew that.
(2) Feels deeply sorry; oh God, yes! I am so, so sorry for all the pain I caused her. I did spend some time in her life trying to make up for it. But, I believe she must know by now how I so regret it.
(3) Be fully accepting of me for who I am: I know for sure that Leslie knew I accepted and loved her for her. I made the effort to never judge but always be on her side and supportive and encouraging. I got excited with her at each victory and opening door in her life. I called her my hero.
(4) Want me in his life, unconditionally: Yay! That’s an easy one. I needed Leslie in my life. I called her every week. We both made the effort to spend time together and try to stay current on all the adventures in our lives. Of course, except for my moving out to California and the occasional celebrity sighting, most of the excitement came from Leslie’s adventures in pursuing her dreams.
In the face of all these criteria, it appears that, yes, it is quite reasonable to believe deeply in my heart that Leslie forgives me. So, to continue blaming myself would be against her wishes. I do believe that she would want me to go on and be happy and do great things. With the help of my coach, I realized I could honor her by carrying on her legacy of giving and selflessness and the pursuit of my own dreams. This, dear sister, is what I commit to do in loving and grateful remembrance of you.
And, my mother’s forgiveness? Thankfully, while I was crying after finishing writing my commitments to Leslie, the answer was right in front of me. If I succeed in being the mother I need to be for my sister, I know I could never blame or be unable to forgive my children for anything. And, more over, I would want so desperately for them to be happy and fulfilled in their lives. I know that underneath my mother’s illness, she was exactly this type of mom. She had proven over and over, when she could, that she would sacrifice anything to give us the opportunities we needed to have this same kind of life. I know now that my mother, too, forgives me and would like nothing better than to see me living a full life – with a loving husband, a good strong family, and enough resources so that I never have to go without again. Thank you, mom, I know you did the best you could. And, I commit to you to always be free in spreading around all my love, affection, and appreciation to all the people and little creatures I hold dear. I love you.
And, now, I march ever more strongly back into battle with my monster. I now have the love and support of my family behind me, and in honor of them, I will succeed.