Let’s talk about it.
It’s depressing. It’s horrifying.
But, it happens. We need to talk about it. I realize that this post is a bit meandering. But, as happens sometimes, I just want to write out all my thoughts, as meandering as they may be. I hope you can get something out of it, too.
I’ve been listening to the CD of Man's Search for Meaning by Viktor E. Frankl, and he talks about suicide a lot, so I've been thinking about it a lot (plus, it seems to be occurring in our little community quite a bit lately). He blames it mostly on what he calls the “existential vacuum” which is the lack of an identifiable purpose in life, having no clear reason to live. It is a cross-cultural and age-independent experience and problem. It’s not that an individual’s circumstances are so obviously horrific or unbearable. Rather, it’s that there is just no clear reason to continue on.
This vacuum can happen to rich and poor alike; to people who seemingly have everything in the world – just no purpose. It happens a lot to parents after their children are grown and have moved away. It happens to older people after their spouse passes away. It happens to people who finally achieve a long-standing dream. This is what happened to me after I finished college. My big childhood dream was to get into a good college. After that was done, I had no idea what to do next, and I feel into a depression.
This explanation doesn’t explain my sister, Leslie’s suicide 3 years ago. She had a purpose and big dreams that were very important to her. She had a little sister in the Big Brother/Big Sister program, who was just the light of her life. They had been together for quite a few years. She also loved her job of a makeup artist – it was her creative passion and her profession (the perfect match). She had concrete and developing plans for one day creating a non-profit organization dedicated to helping poor women to get on their feet and get out in the world and get a career. Leslie would never admit it, but our mother was her inspiration. It was very hard for our mom to go out and get a job when she barely had a tooth left in her head. She had no professional clothes except a few that were about 20 years old, and she certainly couldn’t afford any new ones when buying gasoline and food and paying bills were weekly challenges. Her car was a broken down rust-bucket that couldn’t be relied on to get her to a job, forget about the interview. Her glasses were broken and her winter coat was ripped. It’s no wonder she couldn’t get up the nerve to get out in the world and “just get a job” like I was always pleading with her and yelling at her about. (I believe this is all part of the reason my mom gave up so easily when she was hospitalized before her death. She seemed quite ready and willing to go.)
But, Leslie had other problems. She had binge eating disorder, and she had lupus. Her lupus gave her bad arthritis which made her makeup work painful. She would get really bad hives from exposure to the sun, while the beach had always been her refuge and favorite place in the world. She was always battling infections and exhaustion and arthritis pain.
I can’t say exactly why Leslie decided death was better. But, I appreciate that her chronic conditions were definitely a daily challenge for her. And, this really pains me to say it, but I feel that she was more angry than sad when she died. Her note had an angry edge to it. I think she believed she was doing the ultimate act of revenge against those who hurt her, like our parents who did a terrible job raising us and her biological mom who put her up for adoption to end up with such a crazy and messed up family as mine. I can’t analyze it any more than that. I may be completely wrong, and I hope I am, but that is how I feel about it. That makes me so sad. I know how powerfully self-destructive anger can be. It’s bad enough to think about her in so much pain that suicide seemed like the best solution. But, it’s really sad to think of her suffering that depth of unrelenting and inconsolable rage. Perhaps she had to work up a rage to give her the final courage to take those pills. I don’t know. I’ve said it many times before – my rage caused me infinitely more pain than my bulimia ever did.
Let’s look at Jeremy. Most of you know a bit about him. He talks about suicide regularly, and many of us fear the worst. I believe Frankl’s existential vacuum applies to him completely. Jeremy has tried to find meaning. The book he has been wanting to write about his life has provided him with some sense of purpose. He appears optimistic and dedicated when he senses support for this goal. And, he gets depressed and suicidal when his goal is challenged or threatened. I can see why Jeremy is a bit lost. He spent his childhood in treatment centers. I bet he learned in childhood that his purpose and goal was simply to get better – to become “normal.” I can’t see how any other dreams or talents could have been encouraged or fostered in that environment. His sickness is all he knows of himself. That’s what all the adults saw in him. That’s what they related to in him. If I were him, I would be very angry and resentful. I would also be incredibly fearful because I wouldn’t know myself underneath all that.
And, then there is the boredom. Frankl says that chronic boredom has caused more depression and suicidal thoughts than any life-threatening life circumstance. He says that as the world modernizes and less time is required for work, depression continues to climb. That goes against expectations that as leisure time increases, happiness would increase. As leisure time increases, in fact, man’s sense of purposelessness has increased, and so too, then, has depression. It seems there is some of this playing out for Jeremy.
I’ve spoken with Jeremy a few times on the phone, and you know what really strikes me above all else? His sense of humor. He is incredibly clever and funny. It’s a very dry sense of humor, of course. And, it could easily freak out someone who doesn’t understand his lifestyle – which you and I do to some extent. But, that makes it even funnier. In my humble, ignorant opinion, I wish Jeremy would write his story with all that dry, obnoxious, horrifying humor that is in him. THAT would be a real seller. I see his ability to find things to laugh at in his world as a huge strength. But, of course, only Jeremy can decide how to interpret and live his life.
What is the cure then? Every human will have to find his/her own path to a sense of purpose, since we’re all very different and our paths are so different. But, he does say that suffering does give life a lot of meaning. He seems to say that the ones who have suffered the most may actually have the most to live for. I know that for me, my suffering has given me the purpose (and skills and experience) of helping others to rise above their own pain and desperation – or at least to give some comfort. I want to give comfort to as many humans and animals as I possibly can. I feel joy when I can make a stranger smile, when I can say a kind word to a stranger, when I can help out a stranger. Why strangers rather than friends? Because I never know what pain a stranger may be in. I never know what desperate situation he/she may be struggling through. I never know if my smile may be the only gesture of kindness –of connection- he/she may have experienced all day. I never know if that man I help out is in as much pain as our dear Jeremy. And, don’t you just wish everyone Jeremy comes across could be kind and gentle and generous with him?
The key thing Frankl keeps coming back to is that if an individual can find a “why” to live, he can endure almost any “how.” Maybe someone’s purpose is to create art or music or literature. Perhaps it’s to help children or animals or others in need – even if it’s just the strangers we encounter each day. Perhaps it’s simply to live as good a life as possible – to keep one’s thoughts and words and actions in line with one’s deepest values. It doesn’t have to be a big or grand purpose, it has merely to be enough.
As long as there is free will, there will be suicides. The best we can do as a society is to foster each child’s talents and interests and his/her self-confidence, creativity, and optimism, as well as a sense of wonder and the courage to try, to make mistakes, and at times, to fail. We must teach compassion and forgiveness like I learned at the late (but not too late) age of 34, so that regret and resentment don’t eat away at a child’s soul. This child would have the inner strength to endure the challenges and pain we find in life sometimes. This child would have the instinct to seek out and create his own fulfillment – not just pleasure. This child would thrive.






